FLAVOR LOG // 027

Good Humor Toasted Almond, Part 1: Discontinued


In 2022, Good Humor discontinued its Toasted Almond ice cream bar. It had been around for more than 60 years.

For generations, it was part of the ice cream truck experience. The combination of almond, vanilla ice cream, and that distinctive crunchy coating gave it an identity of its own. It was one of Good Humor's classic bars, alongside Chocolate Éclair and Strawberry Shortcake. The three were relaunched together in 1992, cementing their place in the brand's history. Then Toasted Almond sadly faded into ice cream history.

When we secured the Good Humor license for Flavor52, we knew we wanted it in the lineup. Iconic. Unmistakable. And the #1 Dad ice cream ever. The fact that it had been discontinued didn't change any of that. If anything, there was something particularly fitting about including a flavor that people remembered but could no longer find in the freezer aisle.

There was one small problem with that plan. We couldn't buy one to taste.

When we're developing a flavored coffee inspired by an existing product, we normally try to get the original. It gives us a baseline. We can taste it, identify the characteristics that make it recognizable, and use that experience to guide the development process. It's a useful way to keep our own interpretation from drifting too far from the thing we're trying to recreate. When making the Toasted Almond flavored coffee, that wasn't an option. We needed to rely on something else. Memory.

Our sensory panel had its own collective memory of the bar. The goal was to draw on those shared impressions of what made it taste like Toasted Almond. The panel discussed and agreed on the flavor experience we wanted to capture.

That sheds light on the power of nostalgia. How accurately do we remember the taste of something we haven't eaten in years? And yet ask anyone who ate one, and they’ll swear they remember exactly how it tasted. Smell and taste are closely connected to memory. A familiar food can bring back a particular time or place with surprising clarity. Sometimes you remember the experience long after you've forgotten the details surrounding it. That kind of memory is useful when you're developing a flavor. When the original is gone, a strong memory can give you a direction to follow.

For us, Toasted Almond was a chance to bring a familiar flavor back into the world in a different form. We weren't trying to bring the ice cream bar itself back. We wanted to give its flavor a place in Flavor52, where people could experience it again through coffee.

Most of the time, we're introducing something new or putting a different spin on something familiar. Here, we were working with a flavor that had already earned its place in people's memories. The bar was discontinued, not the memories.

That was enough reason to put Toasted Almond on our list.

MISSION STATUS: We're Bringing Classics Back
Flavors Released: 16 / 52
Ice Cream Truck Season 2: 8 of 9 weeks
Mondays Missed: 0
World Record Status: On track

Back to blog