FLAVOR LOG // 029

Behind the Flavor: I Scream

 

Pumpkin and toffee caramel seemed like a natural pairing for Halloween. They're warm, rich, and full of the browned, buttery notes that make fall desserts so appealing. Put them together, and you get more of the same. That's fine, but it can be a little one note when it comes to flavor complexity. The trick is making sure all that warmth doesn't become too much of a good thing.

For the dual flavors in I Scream coffee, pumpkin and toffee occupy the same flavor family, but they don't contribute the same things. Pumpkin is comparatively mellow, with a softer character that lingers. Toffee caramel is more concentrated, buttery, and intensely browned. Pumpkin gives the caramel a broader foundation, while the caramel gives the pumpkin more depth and definition. Each contributes something the other doesn't.

The added dimension came from the ice cream flavor, which turned out to be a welcome foil to the richness of the warm flavors. Pumpkin and toffee caramel share a lot of cozy, browned territory. Without some contrast, that warmth can become heavy.

It was the same subtle note we chased in Klondike, the one you'd never call sour in ice cream but would miss the second it was gone. That tang is the thing that jumps out of the dark. It cuts through the richness and lets the pumpkin and toffee read as separate flavors instead of one brown blur.

The flavor was designed for Halloween, so there had to be a scream somewhere. We'd spent much of the Ice Cream Truck working out what makes ice cream taste like ice cream, there had to be ice cream.

Put those together, and the rest of the chant writes itself.

Development Notes

  • Pumpkin and toffee caramel overlap heavily and read heavy together.
  • The ice cream tang made it different than regular pumpkin spice. It added contrast without making the flavors feel disconnected.

MISSION STATUS: We All Scream/Season 2 Complete

Flavors Released: 17 / 52
Ice Cream Truck Season 2: 9 of 9 weeks 
Mondays Missed: 0
World Record Status: On Track

Terug naar blog